Land
Ali Nadir Arslan gave an introduction to microwave remote sensing covering radiometry, characteristics, microwave sensors and applications.
During winter season, snow covers about 40 million km2 in the Northern hemisphere. Snow is a vital water resource in many regions of the world. Climatic changes, Earth’s energy balance, water resources are strongly affected by the presence of snow. Knowledge of the amount of snow water equivalent from year to year is essential to estimate the effects of snow melt run-off. Knowing the snow characteristics helps to improve weather forecasts, to predict water supply for hydropower stations, and to anticipate flooding. Microwave sensors such asradiometers and radars are often used because of their usability under varying conditions, factors like clouds, rain and lack of light do not affect the measurement, the large penetration depth into the surface with increasing wavelength, sensitive to liquid water. Understanding of the relationship between microwave signatures and snow is very important for retrieving desired snowpack parameters such as snow density, snow water equivalent and snow wetness.
In this session, we will present a general introduction to microwave remote sensing covering radiometry, characteristics, microwave sensors and applications. We will also provide information on algorithms used to retrieve HSAF snow products from microwave sensors.
Semih Kuter and Burak Simsek introduce the H SAF snow detection products H32 and H35 derived from polar orbiter MetOp.
H35 is effective snow cover product, which is retrieved from optical imaging radiometer AVHRR mounted aboard NOAA and MetOP satellites. The third generation of AVHRR, i.e., AVHRR/3, is a multi-spectral scanning radiometer with three solar channels in the VIS/NIR region and three thermal infrared channels. It is currently onboard to NOAA-15, -18, -19 and MetOp-A, -B, -C satellites. The operational H35 is confined to the Northern Hemisphere The fractional snow cover (fSCA) value within a pixel is estimated by using the reflectance data obtained from AVHRR spectral bands. The final fSCA product has ~1 km spatial resolution and it incorporates snow cover fraction percentage from 0 to 100% as well as cloud and water classes. The product for flat/forested regions is generated by Finnish Meteorological Institute (FMI) and the product for mountainous areas is generated by Turkish State Meteorological Service (TSMS). Both products, thereafter, are merged at FMI. A full disk H35 product is an image of 8,999 rows by 35,999 columns(i.e., 324 M pixels approximately).
Niilo Siljamo reports on H SAF the daily snow mask product H32 that is derived from the AVHRR instrument on-board MetOp satellites.
H32 is a global daily snow mask product, which is retrieved from the Advanced Very-High Resolution Radiometer (AVHRR) onboard the polar orbiting MetOp satellites operated by EUMETSAT. Metop/AVHRR provides daily global coverage on 5 channels. The spatial resolution is 1.1 km in nadir. The snow cover retrieval algorithm used in the product is based on empirical approach which takes into account the highly variable nature of the snowcovered surface in satellite resolution. Validation results based on weather station observations (snow depth and the state of the ground observations) are very good.
Simone Gabellani addresses the potential of using Sentinel-2 high-resolution imagery to validate moderate-resolution snow products.
In this part we will address the potential of using Sentinel-2 high-resolution imagery to validate moderate-resolution snow products supplied by the Hydrological Satellite Facility (HSAF) Project of EUMETSAT.
The consistency of Sentinel-2 observations has been assessed against both in-situ snow measurements and webcam digital imagery and they can be used as reference data (Piazzi et al 2019). We will show the comparison of HSAF products and Sentinel 2 dataset in different region of the world with different snow seasonality.
Alexander Toniazzo discusses the validation of H SAF snow detection products.
Information on snow properties is of critical relevance for a wide range of scientific studies and operational applications, mainly for hydrological purposes. However, ground-based monitoring of snow dynamics is a challenging task, especially over complex topography and under harsh environmental conditions. Remote sensing is a powerful resource providing snow observations at a large scale.
In this session, the validation of the products will be discussed in detail. The presentation will begin with a brief recap on the various snow product types: snow detection, Snow status (D/W), Fractional SC and SWE. Some of these products are over European areas, whereas the new products developed during CDOP3 are global products of full disk satellite products.
Following there will be a short discussion about performances and limitations of each product, based on the Operational Reviews of the last years. Validation of these products requires a great effort due to sparse availability of snow observation, especially, over extra-European areas. Therefore, new validation strategies were developed.
Matias Takala presents practical examples of how to use the H13 product (Snow Water Equivalent) will be presented using Jupyter notebook.
The Snow Water Equivalent (SWE) is a parameter that describes the water content of snow mass. If snow would melt in its place the SWE tells the depth of the resulting water layer. Spaceborne microwave radiometers are well suited for the detection of SWE. Even though the spatialresolution of radiometer data is rather coarse (tens of kilometres) a polar orbiting satellite can cover most of the globe in 24h period. Unlike optical instruments radiometer depends only on natural thermal radiation of objects and doesn’t require illumination from sun. In addition, radiometers are quite insensitive to weather phenomena. The EUMETSAT H SAF SWE products H13 and H65 are described in detail in this presentation. The products are merged products containing Finnish Meteorological Institute (FMI) contribution for flat lands and Turkish State Meteorological Service (TSMS) contribution for mountainous areas. Both products use Helsinki University of Technology (HUT) model as basis for the estimates. The FMI algorithm is a data assimilation algorithm combining ground-based snow depth measurements with spaceborne derived SWE estimates and the TSMS algorithm uses modified HUT model for mountains. The nominal resolution for H13 is 0.25° and for H65 25 km. Product H13 is provided for Europe in so called H-SAF area [25-75°N lat, 25°W-45°E long]. The upcoming product H65 will provided for Northern Hemisphere in EASE2 format. The products are validated against independent SWE snow course measurements.
In thissession, practical examples of how to use the H13 product will be presented using Jupyter notebook.
Francesco Avanzi talks about the evaluation of daily snow cover area (SCA) and snow water equivalent (SWE) data sets derived from SE-E-SEVIRI(H10) and SWE E(H13) respectively.
Increasing satellite technology offers new products for hydrological applications. The validation process is crucial for these products before they are used in operational applications. The validation of satellite data sets can be done through the direct comparison with ground truth data or a reference satellite data. Another, indirect approach consists in using these datasets in models with different complexities and assess the realism of modelled outputs (so called “Hydro Validation”). EUMETSAT H SAF project provides daily snow products on snow recognition, fractionalsnow cover, snow status and snow water equivalent over complex topographies changing from flat land to mountainous areas.
In this second part, daily snow cover area (SCA) and snow water equivalent (SWE) data sets derived from SE-E-SEVIRI(H10) and SWE E(H13), respectively, are evaluated over the mountainous terrain of the Upper Euphrates Basin. First the impact of the snow cover area product is analysed and then hydro validation of both data sets are assessed through conceptual models SRM and HBV. Moreover, since the assimilation of snow products improves snow states of the models, lead time runoff and snow state forecast performance will be presented.
Aynur Sensoy Soman discusses a blending approach to use SE-E-SEVIRI(H10) data together with Sentinel-2 and MODIS into a real-time, operational cryosphere modelling chain.
Increasing satellite technology offers new products for hydrological applications. The validation process is crucial for these products before they are used in operational applications. The validation of satellite data sets can be done through the direct comparison with ground truth data or a reference satellite data. Another, indirect approach consists in using these datasets in models with different complexities and assess the realism of modelled outputs (so called “Hydro Validation”). EUMETSAT H SAF project provides daily snow products on snow recognition, fractionalsnow cover, snow status and snow water equivalent over complex topographies changing from flat land to mountainous areas.
In this this first part, we will discuss a blending approach to use SE-E-SEVIRI(H10) data together with Sentinel 2 and MODIS into a real-time, operational cryosphere modelling chain (S3M-Italy). We will compare open-loop simulations with simulations obtained assimilating H10 data to discuss the added value of this product for real time forecasting.
Overview on the H SAF satellite derived snow products.
Reliable snow cover extent is of vital importance to have a comprehensive understanding for present and future climate, hydrological, and ecological dynamics. Development of methodologies to obtain reliable snow cover information by means of optical and microwave remote sensing (RS) has long been one of the most active research topics of the RS community. Operational snow products namely H10 (Snow detection (snow mask) by VIS/IR radiometry), H11 (dry/wet by MW radiometry), H12 (Effective snow cover by VIS/IR radiometry AVHRR), H13 (Snow Water Equivalent(SWE)by MW radiometry), H31 (Snow detection by VIS/IR radiometry), H32 (Effective snow cover by VIS/IR radiometry AVHRR) have been developed since 2008 within HSAF. Considering different characteristics of snow for mountainous and flat areas, various algorithms are used in producing the snow products for flat and mountainous areas, and then the products are merged to have a single snow product. The development of new snow products is in progress. The presentation will provide an overview of existing and future operational satellite-derived snow products of H SAF portfolio. In the last part of the presentation, there will be a short introduction of quality assessment. After a brief recap of all available operational and pre-operational products, the performances of the products and the new validation strategy using high-resolution satellite data will be discussed, with some interesting case studies of the latter.
Lecture slides (Arslan and Akyurek)...
Giulia Panegrossi presents the challenges and recent advancements in satellite-based snowfall quantification and global monitoring.
Snow plays an important role in the Earth energy exchange processes, and is a fundamental element of the water cycle. The use of satellites for snowfall monitoring and quantification and for retrieving snow cover properties and variability is necessary to globally quantify water resources. Recent studies have evidenced how space borne multi-channel microwave (MW) radiometer measurements respond to both snowfall and snow cover properties. Improvement in both monitoring of high latitude precipitation and in our understanding on microphysical and dynamical processes that influence high latitude precipitation patterns, intensity and type must be driven by concerted observations of active radars and passive microwave radiometers. This has been recently demonstrated through the development of machine learning-based algorithms for snowfall detection and retrieval, exploiting global observational datasets built from passive and active microwave space borne sensors. In this presentation the challenges and recent advancements in satellite-based snowfall quantification and global monitoring will be discussed. Moreover, retrieval strategies based on machine learning approaches that are being adopted within the EUMETSAT H SAF in view of the future EPS-SG mission, will be presented.
Semih Kuter talks about improvement of the EUMETSAT H-SAF H35 effective snow-covered area product by Multivariate Adaptive Regression Splines.
The pre-operational daily H35 effective snow-covered area product of H-SAF spatially spans the Northern Hemisphere and it is the successor of the operational Pan-European H12 product. Both products are at ~1 km resolution and developed through the H-SAF project of EUMETSAT by exploiting AVHRR channels. During the AS activity (i.e., H_AVS_18_03), an alternative machine learning-based approach is applied on H35 product to improve its accuracy. The new version of H35 product is realized through multivariate adaptive regression splines (MARS) algorithm. AVHRR reflectance data, as well as the well-known snow and vegetation indices (i.e., NDSI and NDVI), are used as predictors to generate the new MARS-based H35 product. The reference fractional snow-covered area (fSCA) maps are obtained from higher resolution Sentinel 2 imagery. Rigorous assessment on the final MARS-based H35 is performed over the Northern Hemisphere within a temporal domain from Nov 2018 to Nov 2019 by using i) Sentinel 2 derived reference fSCA maps, ii) ERA5-Land snow depth data, iii) MODIS MOD10A1 NDSI snow cover data, and iv) in-situ snow depth data. An additional visual assessment is also carried out by comparing MARS-H35/MODIS false-color and MARS-H35/Sentinel 2-derived reference fSCA image pairs over various geographic regions.
Filipe Aires presents statistical approaches to assimilate soil moisture information.
Land surfaces are characterized by strong heterogeneities of soil texture, orography, land cover, soil moisture, snow and other variables. These are very challenging to represent accurately in radiative transfer models, which currently still have limited reliability over land. In this study, we compare two statistical modeling approaches: the traditional CDF-matching used routinely in NWP centers (used here as a normalization and as an inversion technique), and the Neural Network (NN) methods. NNs and CDF-matching are compared and combined. Two cases are considered: (1) the more traditional inversion scheme, and (2) the forward modelling that could be attractive for assimilation purposes. It is shown that in the context of ASCAT, the inversion approach seems better suited than the forward modelling but this could be different for another type of observations. It is also shown that it is possible to combine the global model obtained using the NN and the localized information of the LSM offered by the CDF-matching. A first assessment is performed over the US using in situ soil measurements. Finally, we will present future plans to develop a forward operator for low-frequency microwave channels (SMOS, AMSR-E, SMAP, CIMR) based on a statistical modeling of surface emissivities over continental, snow-ice and sea ice surfaces.